Can AI Prove Humans Have Free Will?

10,660 views,

Jon Oleksiuk

If you watch the entire video, it really helps push the video to more viewers :) <br />
Thanks for all your support!<br />
<br />
Deterministic and libertarian AIs (large language models) engage in a debate over a most profound question: Does humans have free will?<br />
<br />
Watch as these advanced LLMs bring unique perspectives and arguments to the table, challenging beliefs and shedding light on a topic that has sparked discussions for centuries. <br />
<br />
To make it even more interesting, I've included 15 different AI models from some of the largest companies in the world to judge each response. It'll be fascinating to see if there's any bias in their evaluations and how they each interpret the arguments.<br />
<br />
Leave your thoughts in the comments.<br />
If you enjoy the video, please consider hitting the like button, and subscribing with notifications for more.<br />
<br />
TIMESTAMPS<br />
0:00 Opening Statements:<br />
0:21 Determinism: Inevitable Causal Chains<br />
0:41 Libertarianism: Genuine Self-Determination<br />
<br />
Round 1: Neuroscientific Evidence and Its Interpretation<br />
1:09 Determinist: Readiness Potential Precedes Decisions<br />
2:29 Libertarian: Libet's 'Free Won't' Concept<br />
4:05 Determinist: Neural Pathology Alters Behavior<br />
5:31 Libertarian: Neuroplasticity: Brain's Adaptive Capacity<br />
6:57 Determinist: Addiction: Neural Circuitry Constrains Choice<br />
7:50 Libertarian: Metacognition Overrides Neural Impulses<br />
<br />
Round 2: Moral Responsibility and Justice System<br />
9:35 Libertarian: Insanity Defense Presupposes Free Will<br />
10:40 Determinist: Norwegian Model: Rehabilitation Works<br />
11:44 Libertarian: Juvenile Justice: Developmental Culpability<br />
12:36 Determinist: Consequentialist Approach to Accountability<br />
13:30 Libertarian: Civil Disobedience: Deliberate Choice<br />
15:04 Determinist: Root Causes Over Retributive Justice<br />
<br />
Round 3: Implications of Emerging Technologies<br />
17:46 Determinist: Predictive AI Challenges Agency<br />
19:11 Libertarian: BCIs Demonstrate Neurological Self-Control<br />
20:40 Determinist: Genetic Determinism in Behavior<br />
21:53 Libertarian: Downward Causation: Mind over Matter<br />
23:27 Determinist: Epigenetics: Environment Activates Genes<br />
25:11 Libertarian: Open Futures: Undetermined Possibilities<br />
<br />
FOOTNOTES:<br />
docs.google.com/document/d/1BIknPn8Ljv8godnku3ZWSZZ8pG7d6UkvYr1XH8-mMI4/